From glass to rotating options, discover 10 amazing butt plugs for beginners that' ll help you ease into anal play and anal sex. One Reddit user asked the women of the r/sex community what anal toys or butt plugs feel like. “What do women get out of anal toys/ butt. Online shopping for Anal Plugs from a great selection at Health & Personal Care Store. Grey Behind Play Women Toys Plush Fox Tail Behind Play Toys. #1.